Posted by Der-D:
Aside from that though, I really loved the script. I thought that for the most part the writers really tried to be true to Tolkien's language and tone, even during the parts when the dialogue wasn't lifted right from the book.
Yes, there are some parts where they've put parts of Tolkien's description into the movie dialogue, it worked well
Posted by Silur:
@Georgi: Moulin Rouge? Thanks for the tip. I'll see it. My guess it's on the theme "boy doesn't get girl". Have any tips on the "darth vader wins" genre?
Well, I'll let you see it... IMO it does have a rather Shakespearian quality to it. Ummm... the best one I can think of currently is Usual Suspects... it's not exactly Darth Vader wins, but it has a good ending
Posted by Maharlika:
One of them the lack of characterization and development between the uncommon friendship between Legolas and Gimli. (I just loved that contest they had during the siege at Helm's Deep.)
Hopefully it will be developed more over the next two movies though.
Originally posted by Mr Sleep
@DD, i think it would have been better if Peter Jackson tried to do his own film, rather than attempting to convert the book to film in the guise of "How Tolkein Wanted It", i always view film making as a personal thing, if you are taking someone elses vision then one should make it their own and work from their, i dont think he did that.
I think he did do that... It's possible for it to represent his own vision of the books and still be fairly faithful to the books... As to how Tolkien wanted it, well... he didn't
For everyone waiting with baited breath for the next instalment - I found this on Ian McKellan's website, I believe the topic was mentioned some time back:
Q: My question refers to the Balrog. It was a truly amazing scene in the first film and I hunger for more exposure to Durin's Bane. Can you confirm that we will see more of Gandalf's battle with the Balrog: perhaps as a flashback when Gandalf tells the tale of his battle against such a powerful foe?
A: Your question would be better addressed to Peter Jackson who is currently editing and preparing The Two Towers in Wellington, New Zealand. But we have filmed sequences which could be part of a flashback to Gandalf's fate after his fall from the bridge in the Moria Mines.