ToB Paladin Weapons: Carsomyr vs. Purifier

Orland · Post by **Orland** » Fri Jul 13, 2001 11:56 pm

These are the things to look at when you are choosing your holy sword:

a) What weapon skill you like to use?

b) Do you like to use a shield or another weapon?

c) How many paladins will be in your group.

Personally, I think if you're looking into ratios, min & max damage, your missing the point of this being a game of fun. It's not a science what weapon to pick, you just have to decide.

I personally use a Purifier & Foebane combo (currently). I do, however, switch off of dual wielding and to a shield of harmony when I'm fighting a heavy magic situation.

I also have Keldorn in my Party using Carsomyr.

While I'm not a 100% sure, could someone who still has their 2nd Edition P-n-P rules tell me if they allowed +6 weapons or higher? Last I knew weapons only went up to +5.

Bah, that's only if you are considering transfering your character to P-n-P though.

Anyways, think how you usually play, how much fun you have playing with a certain weapon, and the choice should be obvious.

Orland

leeho730 · Post by **leeho730** » Sat Jul 14, 2001 12:21 am

Only weapons with +6 enchantment will hit the final boss. Other than that I'll go for the purifier (and shield). I haven't checked the dispel ability of Carsomyr +6 but my cleric could dispell almost everything.

Xyx · Post by **Xyx** » Sat Jul 14, 2001 1:36 am

Originally posted by Orland:
<STRONG>While I'm not a 100% sure, could someone who still has their 2nd Edition P-n-P rules tell me if they allowed +6 weapons or higher? Last I knew weapons only went up to +5.</STRONG>

Never seen anything like it. Was probably put in because the designers felt the uber, the merrier... If you already have +5 weapons in SoA, what would you do for ToB?

Lucian_Garland · Post by **Lucian_Garland** » Sat Jul 14, 2001 12:26 pm

bioware had repeatedly said that +6 weapons would NOT be required to hit anything
+5 weapons on the other hand..

leeho730 · Post by **leeho730** » Sat Jul 14, 2001 5:04 pm

: Lucian
Try hit the final boss with +5 weapons. (Won't work). I SAID that +6 weapons are needed to hit the FINAL BOSS, but some +5 weapons which do extra damage stuff could hit the final boss for 1 or 2 pt of damage.

Pebz · Post by **Pebz** » Sat Jul 14, 2001 5:14 pm

now THATS a spoiler...

Lucian_Garland · Post by **Lucian_Garland** » Sat Jul 14, 2001 5:53 pm

that is not true, i beat melissan without using any of the +6 weapons

leeho730 · Post by **leeho730** » Sat Jul 14, 2001 6:11 pm

Sarevok (I was playing evil) using ravager +6 could hit the final boss (I won't tell the name), but Korgan and my PC (using +5 hammer and longsword) couldn't hit

(weapon ineffective). Fallen deva managed to hit. Yes you can win without +6 weapon (Sarevok was the only one with +6 weapon anyway), but my point is that you need +6 weapon to HIT, not win. Hope this helps.

moriveth · Post by **moriveth** » Sun Jul 15, 2001 2:19 am

I thought that Carsomyr really inflicts 1d10, not 1d12 as claimed?

Incidentally, the only fair comparison is Carsomyr vs. Purifier + shield or weapon, since you're not going to waste your off-hand.

R.Carter · Post by **R.Carter** » Sun Jul 15, 2001 5:34 am

Orland, yes the P&P 2nd ed. does include a few of +6 hackers. In the Unearthed Arcana there are a couple (a Holy Avenger and a Defender). I am sure there are a few in the Encyclopedia Magica. Many of the weapons in the BG series have their originals listed in the E.M. If any of you can get your hands on a copy (especially Vol.4), take some time and check them out. Its kinda neat.
R.Carter

Xyx · Post by **Xyx** » Sun Jul 15, 2001 9:01 am

Originally posted by moriveth:
<STRONG>I thought that Carsomyr really inflicts 1d10, not 1d12 as claimed?</STRONG>

That's right; it's bugged. I believe Baldurdash has the fix (as ever).