GameBanshee Forums

@Mike: I have nothing against changing leadership every so often, but what if it comes at a rather bad time (Guild War, or many deserters) Thats why I think it should be more of a council choice to expel someone from the leadership role. Besides, if your busy, thats what Seconds are for. When your gone, they're in command.

Here I must agree with Aegis that a civilised council take the decisions (one man one vote (and not on one self of course)) rather than a primal selection of the leaders. I think that it would be a good idea for the fighter's wing since it would fit "their way". Mages could have a council, the fighters a one-on-one etc.
But all in all it will also be very complicated keeping track of dates and fights were a council would be easier to administrate. Once a month we vote, is he good he will stay if not a new leader will have the chance to show his worth as a leader of one of the great wings. It is easy, fair and fast.

All wings should IMO have the same structure

Originally posted by Xandax:
<STRONG>All wings should IMO have the same structure </STRONG>

agree once again (I am pretty easy going today huh ) it was just and example but it needs to be keept simple other wise we are gonna have or own little EU brrrrr

Originally posted by Garcia:
<STRONG>

Originally posted by Xandax:
[qb]All wings should IMO have the same structure </STRONG>

agree once again (I am pretty easy going today huh ) it was just and example but it needs to be keept simple other wise we are gonna have or own little EU brrrrr [/QB]

Hey - behave or I'll have to summon activist to throw rocks at you

In other words, Let he who is without sin, cast the first stone...


Soo.... Is anyone here without sin, or have we all posted in SYM?

Originally posted by Xandax:
<STRONG>
Hey - behave or I'll have to summon activist to throw rocks at you </STRONG>

LOL

oh yeah! well I am just gonna use my 'call minister' you will need to cast 'protection from coruption' in order to defet me

[ 08-08-2001: Message edited by: Garcia ]

Originally posted by Garcia:
<STRONG>LOL

oh year! well I am just gonna use my 'call minister' you will need to cast 'protection from coruption' in order to defet me </STRONG>

*Fish jumps out of the water, and flies across the room*

*SMACK*

*Smacks Garcia in the face*

Or we could do that again...

Originally posted by Aegis:
<STRONG>*Fish jumps out of the water, and flies across the room*

*SMACK*

*Smacks Garcia in the face*

Or we could do that again...

</STRONG>

thanx I needed that I think I have been working enough now and it is time to go home and get some sleep (do you know that feeling that no matter how much you have to do, you always find time to go to Banshee? )
oh well (Gar)see ya

(Gar)see ya? Heh... Interesting.

Cya later Garcia. Becareful of those fish though.... They might still be coming...

*Smack*

*fish hits the ground next to Garcia*

See?

i would liek to know the basic of promotions i would rather be voted for or appointed by the counsil instead of fighting someone for it simple rivalry can be good but i do not want the blood of a guild fellow on my hands even though i know you don't kill them

I agree with you Nikolai. But, thats not gonna stop us from having fun little tourny's amongst us Block Heads.

for fun fights are ok with me to test each others skills i just do not want to fight for position because that to me is not as good as being chosen the the counsil i don't know just my opinion

Okay - I need to get this straight.

We have settle on the idea of 3 ranks within each wing.
A guild-wing leader
5 of next rank
and the rest of the last rank.

If somebody could find out what the different ranks should be called (Wing-buisness) and PM them to me, then I'll update it when I get back to this board again from my vacation.

Also there seems to be agreement about the voting-system for promotion.
@Nippy - could you mess together some "guidelines"/"rules" and mail them to me so I can post it when I get back.

EDIT: We also need to figure out how we handle multiclasses - what wing they should be member of, if they choose one, or there is sleceted one for them, or something. I don't think they should be member of 2/3 wings

[ 08-08-2001: Message edited by: Xandax ]

Incoming fighter rankings...

Warlord

War Council (Five Members)

The rest of dem Grunts


For multi class, I think it should be what they started out as. So Fighter/ Mage would be in the Fighter wing, and such.

i don't think dual classes and multiclasses shoudl be allowed to hold positions in guild wings just my opinion

@Nikolai: The mutli-class characters shouldn't be denied from holding rank, but there going to have to chose one wing.

Originally posted by Aegis:
<STRONG>I agree with you Nikolai. But, thats not gonna stop us from having fun little tourny's amongst us Block Heads.

</STRONG>

You fighters have such primitive mannerisms. Oh well, swing away, if the practice saves my neck some day.

Well, i find leadership in general to be quite trivial as no individual can make the right decisions everytime (roleplaying my alignment here, don't lynch me), but if you find leadership to be a necessity, it might as well be done properly, less the corrupted taint of evil seep into those in command. I approve of Xandax's ideas on wing-ranks AND class-ranks, and feel the two should be melded. I'll go ahead and work against my ethos by helping to build up this form of leadership. I suggest the lowest rank for the knights of the Divine Wing, paladins, be squire, or some such term. For the Rogues, the lowest rank could be footpad. Take or leave these suggestions. I care not, as this whole affair is a waste of time. There is no order but that of the individual striving for greater good.

@Average Joe: Don't worry. We won't "Lynch" you. Boys, get the kindling!