Shield vs Spirit Armour Spells
Posted: Tue Jul 24, 2007 10:45 am
I have a doubt here, please correct me.
It seems to me that the level 1 spell Shield is far better than the level 4 spell Spirit Armour, but that's not logic; how a level 1 spell would be better than a 4th one?
Here's my analisys:
-Both increase AC in the -armour- type (no deflection, generic, etc.) but Shield gives one more (+7 vs +6)
-Both give +3 reflex saving throws (though Shield only vs area?)
-Shield gives immunity to magic missiles.
-Spirit Armour deals damage when worn off.
-Shield is level 1 and Spirit Armour is 4.
-Both have the same duration
So???? Where are the good things of Spirit Armour over Shield ???
It seems to me that the level 1 spell Shield is far better than the level 4 spell Spirit Armour, but that's not logic; how a level 1 spell would be better than a 4th one?
Here's my analisys:
-Both increase AC in the -armour- type (no deflection, generic, etc.) but Shield gives one more (+7 vs +6)
-Both give +3 reflex saving throws (though Shield only vs area?)
-Shield gives immunity to magic missiles.
-Spirit Armour deals damage when worn off.
-Shield is level 1 and Spirit Armour is 4.
-Both have the same duration
So???? Where are the good things of Spirit Armour over Shield ???