LS or DS what would you pick?

Chanak · Post by **Chanak** » Sun Aug 06, 2006 11:38 am

In order to more fully experience the game, IMO, the three paths should be available: Light Side, Dark Side, and Neutral. As far as what suits my own personal inclinations, I would say the Light Side without question. However, traveling the Dark Side path is one way to experience a different game, and for that I think it's worth doing. I think a possible KOTOR III should offer more in the way of unique experiences for LS, DS, and Neutral Jedis.

superbob263 · Post by **superbob263** » Wed Aug 09, 2006 8:06 pm

x_ray619 wrote:Yea Iwould like to see some cinematics for the gray side to cuz it would make me wanna play it 3 times through instead of just the 2 times cuz I'm bored by the second through and plus if you do choose to play neutral by the end of the game you have to end up choosing between light or dark side anyway. But for the person above me that hasnt played KOTOR 2 on the dark side yet the ending cinematic won't be any better, they both sucked. The first KOTOR's cinematics were so much better.

I Know that would be the coolest scence I am never dark side or light side just in the middle the hole game

moe210 · Post by **moe210** » Sun Aug 13, 2006 12:43 am

Gray side all the way!

I've been an LS follower for a while but the more I think about it, no side is right. The Jedi are fools who restrict their students. The Sith are fools who do nothing but kill mindlessly. The Gray Jedi know how to use the DS. What if there was a medical patient whos heart stopped and you had the chance to save him using an electrical shock? Think of all the times the Jedi code stopped Jedi from killing people who would go on to destroy planets and make slaves of innocent people. I think the game should definately have a choice to be neither and stand alone for a while, then end up meeting people slowly who join your party or something like that.

wombat888 · Post by **wombat888** » Sat Sep 09, 2006 8:27 am

DS or LS

I think the way both are used in the games is silly. There are times when I intend to be nice, and I give a "tough love" answer, and get DS points. There are other times when I intend to lie or cheat people, say friendly things to keep them from realizing what I'm up to, and I get LS points. In general, the LS choices are a lot more rational. The DS choices are most often ridiculous.

As for the powers, I think they are roughly about equal, but the DS attacks are more fun. If you're a consular, it doesn't matter. You can use them both, anyway ... you rarely run out of FP after 12th level or so, anyway.

User45701 · Post by **User45701** » Mon Sep 25, 2006 3:34 pm

The other thread is closed so i will post here i think the dark side is the one and only way to go.
I dont actually pick i side i like to answer everything as i would if i reley had those powers and just see where it takes me

darth humac · Post by **darth humac** » Fri Nov 24, 2006 6:01 pm

I dont think I would like that picking your side before you can even start the game. I like choosing my side during the game.

DarthZ · Post by **DarthZ** » Sat Nov 25, 2006 3:01 am

I wouldnt like to choose in the start either. The KotOR games are supposed to make you dwindle (dunno how to write it) between LS and DS; sure you can if you start DS or LS but it wouldn't be the same. If I chose DS in the start I would probally play that way through whole game which would probally make it more boring.

WorkingClasHero · Post by **WorkingClasHero** » Mon Dec 04, 2006 7:51 pm

I like the idea, although it could probably be better implemented as a "hidden" choice at the end of the prologue (kinda like the male/female/LS/DS Revan in KotOR II), and build two or three distinct plots from there to increase the game's replay value.

FighterTundra · Post by **FighterTundra** » Tue Dec 05, 2006 8:22 am

I would pick both. usually i first do light side completion, then darkside completion, and then i do what i would do in real life

, usually neutral.

DesR85 · Post by **DesR85** » Tue Dec 05, 2006 8:52 am

DarthZ wrote:I wouldnt like to choose in the start either. The KotOR games are supposed to make you dwindle (dunno how to write it) between LS and DS; sure you can if you start DS or LS but it wouldn't be the same. If I chose DS in the start I would probally play that way through whole game which would probally make it more boring.

I agree with you. Being able to choose your path (LS or DS) at the start will take away the open-ended factor of the game. It reminds me of quite a number of strategy games that gives you the option to choose your side/faction. I would much prefer if you do good deeds to earn your way to LS and the opposite for DS, just like how most open-ended RPGs are designed in the first place.

magic80 · Post by **magic80** » Mon Feb 19, 2007 6:32 pm

Pretty good idea. It would be good if the two parties overlapped; for example, if you're a light side jedi you could be with your master, and have a story line involving a sith master and some unknown apprentice (who is unknown for most of the story, appearing at the end). Similarly, a sith character follows his master, and interweaves with a Jedi Master, and hear of a bright young jedi (or something). At one point, the character's master dies (Jedi defending the character if LS, the character murders the Sith master if DS), so they have to go solo. Also, the character can be enticed into changing sides.

Darth_Juro · Post by **Darth_Juro** » Thu Mar 01, 2007 9:13 pm

I'd pick darkside, I find it more fun to play, the only downside I can see is the whole greyish pale deathly look you get when your completely evil which I didn't see anakin all paleish when he fell.

bigredpanda · Post by **bigredpanda** » Fri Mar 02, 2007 6:32 am

Darth_Juro wrote:I'd pick darkside, I find it more fun to play, the only downside I can see is the whole greyish pale deathly look you get when your completely evil which I didn't see anakin all paleish when he fell.

Yes, that's something a SW expert might be able to explain to me: in the Return of the Jedi, we see Vader and the Emperor, and they're both grey and distorted etc. So the games suggest that if you go DS, your apeparance changes. Then, in Revenge of the Sith, the Emperor goes like that because of the reflected force lightning, and Anakin is burned... consistency?

Darth_Juro · Post by **Darth_Juro** » Sat Mar 03, 2007 12:55 pm

yeah, they were both distorted after what a jedi did to them, not because they were evil lol. Also I'm the kinda guy that likes to play as a female character for obvious reason so I don't really want to see a chick with pale chapped grey skin. sorry if this strayed from the topic.

Darth Spawn · Post by **Darth Spawn** » Fri Mar 16, 2007 11:21 am

whats happend to the cold hearted destructive thinker who see the light side is weak the dark side far more powerful HAHAHAHA <language editted: Xandax>

Cyro · Post by **Cyro** » Mon Mar 19, 2007 7:13 am

x_ray619 wrote:Yea Iwould like to see some cinematics for the gray side to cuz it would make me wanna play it 3 times through instead of just the 2 times cuz I'm bored by the second through and plus if you do choose to play neutral by the end of the game you have to end up choosing between light or dark side anyway. But for the person above me that hasnt played KOTOR 2 on the dark side yet the ending cinematic won't be any better, they both sucked. The first KOTOR's cinematics were so much better.

I'd want a 'gray side' line as well, though it's similar to the light side in many ways, mainly because I naturally play as neutral, I dislike the way LS and DS are so clear cut and obvious, I also disagree with the play style of the dark side, I'd want to play a cunning Sith, not one that kills everyone in their path.

Darth Spawn · Post by **Darth Spawn** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 3:49 pm

i tried playing nutruel but i found it difficult to choose your dialoge because you dont want to be a panzy little jedi push over but you dont want to be a insane corrupt killing machine sith

P.S i somehow turned out full dark so uhm i didnt do it write

11Revan26 · Post by **11Revan26** » Sat May 26, 2007 1:05 pm

I would pick all first game i play: light. second:dark. Third: neutril

Nemanja · Post by **Nemanja** » Sun Jul 01, 2007 1:40 pm

None. I would like to be Revan.

OftheRepublic · Post by **OftheRepublic** » Sun Jul 01, 2007 4:04 pm

it is so much more fun to go around killing everything- leveling is easier too when darkside/ i play both just to see how it turns out differently- i just started original kotor and im level 10 dark side most of the way and i have yet to leave taris, i completed every quest on taris all the bounties all the fights except i messed up 1 choice in the undercity village