Evil...
I think playing evil in a game such as this will be alot more then alot of people think. There seems to be a current fad that being evil is cool etc etc.
I personally see that attitude as a real sad example (not saying you artemis this is just a kinda rant on evil)
I will be an evil player, so am I being a hypocrite here? Some may say yes though I will disagree. I have firm clear ideas of what I, Severoth wants to achieve over his career. I also wont be advertising that Im evil in game *hopes people dont metagame* and generally being a quiet and moody individual (given to outbursts of violence and attacking people that insult him in bad situations)
On good and evil in a guild though, I personally have problems. I dont think your wrong for doing so, its just that a guild usually comes together for a joint purpose. Evil people want things and will go at any length (or almost) to get what they want. In a guild of good players you could see alot of conflict and although this would offer for some choice roleplaying aspects it would also put you at the point of what to do with evil characters that break the law? They would be a problem to the guilds good standing, and you may have to eject people from the guild to save your reputation and even then ejecting people would not change that alot.
To me a guild is a group of like minded people in RL who all want to achieve the same goals in game. I personally see alignments that contradict each other such as good and evil not being in them. I can see good and neutral or neutral and evil but the two extremes. Although it might offer alot of roleplaying options it could also cause you to loose members in game which would be a shame since you have all waited so long to be a guild together.
Also Artemis your character may very well be evil. A good and very basic way to define evil would be to ask your character these questions..
Would I kill someone for money?
Would I sell guildies out for power and money if I can do it without being caught?
Would I kill an innocent to cover my tracks?
Would I kill someone for revenge?
If you answer yes to some of these (or all of them) you are over the line or getting close to it.
On the revenge note saying yes is not really evil but getting close to it. It all depends why they killed the person or people that are close to you for. What if they are killing because your master hurt them? Possibly a person should look into this.
If you did play a neutral evil character you are wholly out for yourself. You dont care about killing your mother for money or selling your best mates out. Its all about getting ahead. There is only one person in this world you care about and its you.
Yes there are some situations where they may stick with you through thick and thin, but ultimately a neutral evil character cant be relied upon. One day someone will offer them a deal they cant refuse (their life) and they may just sell you out.
I personally will be a lawful evil character. A set rigid line of ethics that I hold that make me a better person. I wont have qualms about killing people get in my way, but I can still appreciate the benefits of my guild and why I stick with them.
A fairly long rant, but evil just makes me feel the need to type. also these are my views on things and not anyone elses so dont take them to heart
Also no offence was meant at all