I`ve decided to go with
1. Bard: Donnie Highstrung ( Daughter of Kael Highstrung recently seen in the underdark with an Elf)
Reason: Wanted to play bard a nothing else
2. Druid/Fighter: Dynaheir
Reason: Never played with her and since most people seem to think she rules then Im all for it.
3. Bard: Haer`dalis
Reason: Never played with him neither so hopefully it`ll be a nice experience.
4. Thief/Illusionist: Jan
Reason: I need a thief and I dont like Imoen nor traitors, and Nalia is just out of the question.
5. Inquisitor: Kheldorn
Reason: Since I already have four characters I can just as well brake my pattern right of and go for a fifth guy.
I always have the most fun when playing bards.
Have you got the Gibberlings 3 Song and Silence mod installed?
If you're playing a bard you definetly should. (It adds a new store and improves some of the kits)
1. Is your Pc kitted? if not give the new and improved Jester kit a try. I did and it is now my favourite bard kit!
2. People often claim
Jaheira rules because they view her through rose tinted glasses having for whatever reason hauled her carcass through the first game (in which she wasn't great). Or they despise Anomen's arrogent personality. Overall I've always found Anomen the more useful character as clerics have better healing spells than druids and can turn undead (useful in this game) It all depends on which you find more irritating the arrogant egotism of Anomen or Jaheira's relentless nagging and condescending attitude. (Of course you can also romance Jaheira if your so inclined)
Dynaheir's dead and although she was highly strung she never quite reached Jaheira's levels of nagging.
3. Probably one of the most difficult characters to use effectively. I recomend reading the NPC useage guide at Sorcerer's Place for some tips, it's not gospel but it helped.
Link:
http://www.sorcerers.net/Games/BG2/index_tips.php
4.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2a0b6/2a0b65fb49162e60a25e5243b8f83db2ebf2b389" alt="Big Grin :D"
Jan's great (and I'm not the only one who hates Imoen (yay!))
5. And with two bards, Jan and Jaheira you'll need a good tank
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2a0b6/2a0b65fb49162e60a25e5243b8f83db2ebf2b389" alt="Wink ;)"
On a side note you'll get the most out of Keldorn interaction wise if you take Anomen over Jaheira but again its a matter of how much you enjoy inter-party banter (which I hope you do given your taking Jan)