Please note that new user registrations disabled at this time.

Re: Pen and Paper RPG dying?? (Answer: not if I can help it)

This forum is to be used for all discussions pertaining to any edition of the Dungeons & Dragons role-playing game.
Post Reply
User avatar
stumps
Posts: 1
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 6:53 pm
Contact:

Re: Pen and Paper RPG dying?? (Answer: not if I can help it)

Post by stumps »

I signed up to this forum just to post this Thread because I was searching google and ran into this Archived Thread from this Forum.
[url=Pen and Paper RPG dying??]http://www.gamebanshee.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-14213.html[/url]

In short, the above mentioned thread was a series of questions and concerns from TRPG (t=tabletop) players about the slow of sales or popularity of TRPG's with the growing popularity and ease of PCRPG's.

Basically, their reason for why people stopped playing boiled down to one issue:
PCRPG's are more convenient and less time consuming.

Ok, and that's why people started to play TRPG's through Forums.
But then again...that's not all that great is it?
If you use a Forum, you end up with all sorts of shortcommings,
  1. You have to make a seperate OOC (out of character) thread from the IC (in character) Thread
  2. You have to trust the players to actually Roll the dice without cheating
  3. You have to post any pictures on your own webspace and give the link to the other players
  4. You have to post your character sheet on your own webspace and give the link to the GM(DM).
  5. You have to re-upload your character sheet to your webspace everytime you change something of major importance
and on and on and on....

About the only thing convenient about Forum RPGing (Play-by-Post, or PbPRPGing) is that it's there when you can get to it and you usually only need to spend anywhere from 5 minutes to 30 minutes a day depending on how much you LIKE to play it.

But with all those negatives listed above, it's convinience of time is completely lost.

Until now.
Myself and a small team are underway with a project that is presently in Alpha Testing.
It's slow gowing, but it's moving forward at a pretty good rate.
What are we doing?
Re-viving TRPG's back to life by making a Forum that is built from scratch to support playing TRPG's on.

What this means, in case you might over look it, is that you will be able to play DnD, Star Wars (d6 & d20), Shadowrun, Earthdawn, Whitewolf stuff, GURPS, etc... etc... etc... whatever...on the Forum with FULL support in doing so.

What does full support mean?
It means that
  1. you have a dice roller that is specially designed for EVERY RPG we can make one for, and a General Dice Roller for the ones we haven't been able to yet (the general dice roller is outstanding though! I'd almost use it over special made for system dice rollers)
  2. you have your USER account, but EVERY character you have made has there own PROFILE and Alias!
    What does that mean? It means that the little thing to the left of this message that has my name on it...that thing. It changes with EACH character you have, but you are still logged in as YOUR account. Each character profile gets a different Avatar of your choice too.
  3. you have a SAVED character sheet for every character you have and it's saved in the characters profile. (in Alpha testing this is no more than a blank field for the user to fill in, but we're working on upgrading that to a full on character sheet for each system)
  4. IC/OOC support that is FILTERED. Meaning: you don't have to create a new thread to have OOC talk. You simply click the filter on to see the OOC with or without the IC posts as well.
  5. GM(DM's) will be able to give their players experiance that is saved directly to the character sheet via a click of the mouse.
  6. Game threads will (hopefully) come with storage space for files that the user group might need for the game.
  7. GM(DM) acts as a Thread Moderator for the game Thread.
There's a whole hell of alot more going on with the Forum that we're making.
And I'll keep you guys up to date in the future, if anyone is interested, on what our release date is for this thing.
Right now, we still have months to work on things.
It's moving fast, but when your goal is to support EVERY RPG out there in a Forum...yeah...that's a rather large goal!

{And the reason I'm not saying where to go, or anything like that is because we're in Alpha Testing...meaning...we aren't ready for you to see it yet. We want it to look better before anyone does. :D }
User avatar
Gauda
Posts: 195
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2004 1:32 pm
Location: Norway
Contact:

Post by Gauda »

Wow! Reading this post, I would really like to try DND on this forum, never tried it before on a forum, but the forum you guys are working on sounds to be great!

Keep up the good work! I'm open for beta testing if that's needed :D
<worksoufy> man i need to eat
<Trak3r> that's "yoda" speak for "i need to eat a man"
User avatar
Paranitis
Posts: 343
Joined: Fri Aug 27, 2004 7:26 pm
Location: Sacramento, California USA
Contact:

Post by Paranitis »

This topic made absolutely no sense at all to me.

You want to revive TABLETOP RPGing by playing it online..that isn't TRPG then, it's just playind D&D online with no physical human contact.
User avatar
Dragon21189
Posts: 5
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 2004 10:20 am
Location: England
Contact:

Post by Dragon21189 »

A major problem with any forum version is what happens if a player is required to make a major decision/action but for some reason (powercut,no bill pay,act of god) means that they cant? The game then breaks down? imo bad idea.
Some Say Dragons Dont Exist....After They Tell Me To My Face That I Am A Myth...And Survive "Mythical" Dragon Breath...Let's See If They Can Say Im A Myth
User avatar
MikeCooper
Posts: 22
Joined: Sat Aug 07, 2004 9:36 pm
Location: Pa
Contact:

Post by MikeCooper »

i completely agree with paranitis you preaching a revival but yet you arent contributing lloll
Ownage?
User avatar
Paranitis
Posts: 343
Joined: Fri Aug 27, 2004 7:26 pm
Location: Sacramento, California USA
Contact:

Post by Paranitis »

Woohoo! Vegetarian party at stumps' house! I'll bring the hotdogs!

Catch my meaning?
User avatar
Rob-hin
Posts: 4832
Joined: Tue Aug 21, 2001 11:00 am
Location: In the Batcave with catwoman. *prrrr*
Contact:

Post by Rob-hin »

I don't think p&p is dieing.
Now a days, more and more people play it. But it's not something that you easily talk about (ever tried explaing it to a random friend/person?). Someone you know can play it and you woud never know.

Games like Baldur's gate made people take an interest in it, not stop them from playing it.
Guinness is good for you.
Gives you strength.
User avatar
Paranitis
Posts: 343
Joined: Fri Aug 27, 2004 7:26 pm
Location: Sacramento, California USA
Contact:

Post by Paranitis »

I agree, a lot of people do still play D&D..obviously they have to be playing still if more Pencil/Paper products keep coming out.

D&D isn't exactly something you advertise towards others like you would maybe do with football or basketball.
User avatar
Magrus
Posts: 16963
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 7:10 am
Location: NY
Contact:

Post by Magrus »

I think thats quite a task to undertake. I've never really played a pen and paper roleplaying game myself, I've invested a couple hundred dollars in books over the years on them for research, but haven't found one that I've enjoyed enough to play myself. It does sound quite a bit like a forum based version of the WebRPG software I downloaded a few years ago to try and build my own through there. It had some neat tools to do so, so I grabbed it and tested it. Also had a chat room feature to play your own games in there. Its not freeware anymore so I haven't bothered to get it again and I'm not sure what changes have occurred over the past three or four years with it. I'd have to say if you actually put it together and it was functional as you've said though and put out the time and cost to advertise it somewhere it would gather quite a following over time I would think.

I believe his point was not so much the TABLETOP aspect as the traditional RPG aspect rather than the video game version, and wanting to promote a way for people to do so online in a comprehensive and easy to use manner, or am I wrong in this?

The problems mentioned as in power going out and such are irrevelant. ANYTHING can happen to anyone at any time. Having a session in person and having a person not show because of alternate plans, car accident, sickness, act of god or being run over by an elderly woman in a grocery store parking lot all apply too no?
"You can do whatever you want to me."
"Oh, so I can crate you and hide you in the warehouse at the end of Raiders?"
"So funny, kiss me funny boy!" / *Sprays mace* " I know, I know, bad for the ozone"
Post Reply