Please note that new user registrations disabled at this time.

Would you Die for Your Principles?

Anything goes... just keep it clean.
User avatar
dragon wench
Posts: 19609
Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2001 10:00 pm
Location: The maelstrom where chaos merges with lucidity
Contact:

Would you Die for Your Principles?

Post by dragon wench »

A couple of years ago somebody posted this topic (http://www.gamebanshee.com/forums/showt ... principle), and I remembered it as I was considering some of the subjects that have come up in the pope thread...
Specifically, I got to wondering.. if the new pope was actually coerced into joining the Hitler Youth... This led me to thoughts on the entire topic of morality and coercion more generally.

My question is: If somebody is coerced into a joining a repugnant movement are they morally justified? Similarly, can somebody be excused for heinous acts because they were simply "following orders?"

Would it be more moral to stand up for what you believe in and refuse to act or join, even if that means certain death?
Spoiler
testingtest12
Do not meddle in the affairs of dragons, for you are crunchy and taste good with ketchup.
Spoiler
testingtest12
.......All those moments ... will be lost ... in time ... like tears in rain.
User avatar
CopperWater
Posts: 120
Joined: Thu Jul 17, 2003 3:26 pm
Location: A broken home.
Contact:

Post by CopperWater »

Thinking about it now I think that I would be a coward and join in with such a group but if I was faced with the confrontation and I knew I would be forced the kill people maybe I would die for my beliefs. Its hard to tell, I normaly avoid confrontation and join in the group but I dont know what I would do in such a serious situation.
[color=dark red]When an adult goes to hell its terrific, but when a child goes to hell, well, thats why I am in the business.[/color][/size]
User avatar
Magrus
Posts: 16963
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 7:10 am
Location: NY
Contact:

Post by Magrus »

I'd die for my beliefs. I've come close once already for it. In the case of joining a military body I was against, I'd join in the effort to cause as much harm to the group as possible. Refusing outright with no weapons is certain death with no worth. Joining, training and taking out half a squad at the first opportunity they deploy you to do acts your against, now that is a death worth your life IMO.

As far as being coerced into joining, if you aren't doing so to further your own beliefs, I'd say your corrupt and a coward.

To make it more interesting however, bringing family into it can pose a large number of problems. If you have children, young children, they depend on you to live. You are required to take care of them. Getting shot down for defiance doesn't quite cut it there. Where do you draw the line of going along with something to protect your children and to stand up for what you believe in because all of your deaths are preferrable to joining up with a group that does heinous acts?
"You can do whatever you want to me."
"Oh, so I can crate you and hide you in the warehouse at the end of Raiders?"
"So funny, kiss me funny boy!" / *Sprays mace* " I know, I know, bad for the ozone"
User avatar
CM
Posts: 10552
Joined: Fri May 18, 2001 11:00 am
Location: Here
Contact:

Post by CM »

Yup. No question about. Faith, morals and nation. Hi ho hi ho its off to war we go with razor blades and hand grenades, hi ho hi ho.
For what is it to die but to stand naked in the wind and to melt into the sun? - Khalil Gibran

"We shall fight on the beaches. We shall fight on the landing grounds. We shall fight in the fields, and in the streets, we shall fight in the hills. We shall never surrender!" - Winston Churchill
User avatar
the_limey
Posts: 601
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2003 8:19 pm
Location: Blighty
Contact:

Post by the_limey »

Choice- there is *always* choice, that's what sets us apart from animals. We may not like the alternatives but they are always there.

"We cannot choose what we are, yet what are we but the sum of our choices?"

Also: yes if it was necessary and the right thing I would die for my priciples, for the simple reason that if we have priciples and aren't willing to defend them with our lives we are no better than lawyers.
England expects...
...you to visit:
limey-simey.deviantart.com
User avatar
Xandax
Posts: 14151
Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2000 12:00 pm
Location: Denmark
Contact:

Post by Xandax »

Depends on the principle and situations. There are way to many hypothetical elements to be able to give a "real" answer.
Insert signature here.
User avatar
hodge
Posts: 58
Joined: Fri Feb 25, 2005 12:00 pm
Location: The Death Star

Post by hodge »

no way.
expect,the unexpected
User avatar
FiOth
Posts: 13
Joined: Fri Feb 18, 2005 12:56 am
Contact:

Post by FiOth »

IMO,being made to do something that goes against your morals is like using you as an instrument.Ppl should have the right to act as they will as long as they don't hurt anybody.Freedom(real freedom not the American style"We kill for resources and call ourselves freedom fighters so all idiots around the globe will feel proud") is the most precious thing in any person's life.
User avatar
arno_v
Posts: 1395
Joined: Sun Apr 11, 2004 8:30 am
Contact:

Post by arno_v »

You can't really answer this question if you haven't been in one. I know it would be more moral to stick to your principles and die for them, but I can't predict what I will do if I really have to make such a dicision.
User avatar
ik911
Posts: 4248
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2004 1:43 pm
Location: Having an alibi.

Post by ik911 »

[quote="FiOth]Freedom is the most precious thing in any person's life.[/quote"]That's exactly part of the dilemma. What if there is an enemy force threatening the country that you and your ancestory helped build? Wouldn't you want to defend your country?
And what if you can help achieve higher goals, a better world, by joining an army to fight for the good cause? Wouldn't you want that?
What if you were given the opportunity to take out the scum of the earth and make it a better place for everyone? Wouldn't you do that?
Or what if you can make your family proud? Or all of the above at the same time?
What are your principles worth if you're dead, huh? Anyone thought about that?

I'm a great coward, but if I feel I can make a difference and be of help to a lot of people, I would join a collective like the army. Only when the war I fought is over and history, I will be able to tell if I fought on the good side, or the bad side. You'll never know that in advance. My principle is: "I want to do good", and that is why I would join if my country needs me. But if I can do good in another way, behind an office or in a lab, I would ofcourse prefer that. Decreased chance of getting shot and dying a painful death, you see... :rolleyes:

As it is now, I don't see any reason to join the Dutch Royal Army, because I can't help people by doing nothing of importance or the Navy by sailing on expensive ships that serve absolutely no purpose.
[size=-1]An optimist is a badly informed pessimist.[/size]
User avatar
Brynn
Posts: 4655
Joined: Sun Dec 07, 2003 12:00 pm
Location: Zul'Gurub
Contact:

Post by Brynn »

[QUOTE=CM]Yup. No question about. Faith, morals and nation. [/QUOTE]
Everybody is so quick to give this answer... Have you really thought about it?

I don't think principles are the MOST important thing in life. (Besides, they can prove wrong one day...) Say, the communist come back (god forbid) and try to "persuade" me to join them and be their spy (just like they did to half of the nation a couple of decades ago). Well, if it was just me, I would definitely fight - but what if they threaten with hurting my family? I'm not sure I would keep to my holy principles if the other choice is endanger my loved ones...

[quote="Arno]You can't really answer this question if you haven't been in one. I know it would be more moral to stick to your principles and die for them"]
That's a more diplomatic answer, I second that.
Up the IRONS!
User avatar
Cuchulain82
Posts: 1229
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 3:44 pm
Location: Law School library, Vermont, USA
Contact:

Post by Cuchulain82 »

I tend to think that the truth of a situation depends heavily upon who percieves said "truth". I don't know if I would die for my beliefs, but I think that every time you have to stand up for something, you have to make a choice about value- some things are too important to not stand up for. "Principles" is a vague term- I wouldn't die for my religion (but I'm not religiously active) but I would fight for my family. I would fight to protect someone.

[QUOTE=FiOth]real freedom not the American style"We kill for resources and call ourselves freedom fighters so all idiots around the globe will feel proud"[/QUOTE]
I think you are wrong about this. What kind of freedom to you mean? It is easy to take a manichean approach and just say that "real freedom" is whatever is opposed to GW Bush's perceived imperialism, but in my eyes that is a cop-out. What is "real freedom" that you are talking about- the right to meaningful involvement in government? Rights of women? Rule of law? For centuries "real freedom" has been synonimous with the "American style" of freedom, so don't dismiss it so casually. As for killing for resources, I would first like to know what advanced industrial country doesn't have a history of fighting over resources or profiting from it?
Custodia legis
User avatar
winter rose
Posts: 280
Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2005 8:56 pm
Contact:

Post by winter rose »

There is not a point in believing in something if we are not willing to stand by it at all costs.
A rose to her heart that heaven might bless.
User avatar
arno_v
Posts: 1395
Joined: Sun Apr 11, 2004 8:30 am
Contact:

Post by arno_v »

[QUOTE=ik911]
I'm a great coward, but if I feel I can make a difference and be of help to a lot of people, I would join a collective like the army. Only when the war I fought is over and history, I will be able to tell if I fought on the good side, or the bad side. You'll never know that in advance. My principle is: "I want to do good", and that is why I would join if my country needs me. But if I can do good in another way, behind an office or in a lab, I would ofcourse prefer that. Decreased chance of getting shot and dying a painful death, you see... :rolleyes: [/QUOTE]

Why would you join the army if you're not sure if it's fighting for good causes. You say your principle is "I want to do good" but it seems like you are willing to take the risk of fighting on the bad side as well.
User avatar
ik911
Posts: 4248
Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2004 1:43 pm
Location: Having an alibi.

Post by ik911 »

[quote="arno_v]Why would you join the army if you're not sure if it's fighting for good causes. You say your principle is "]It's the paradox of war. You never know whether you fight on the good side, if there is a good side, because even that can be vague. I'm completely against war, and I can afford that because it's the 21st century.
But back when war was a way to achieve something and I was convinced my side was the good side, I would join the army if I had to, because it would mean I would help the good side win, and that's doing good IMO... The Germans were pretty convinced their side was the good side, and so were the Brittons and the French and the Russians. If I were to be killed in such a war, yes, I would die for my principles, because I would die trying to do good.

hmmm.... What was my point again... :confused:
[size=-1]An optimist is a badly informed pessimist.[/size]
User avatar
Xandax
Posts: 14151
Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2000 12:00 pm
Location: Denmark
Contact:

Post by Xandax »

[QUOTE=winter rose]There is not a point in believing in something if we are not willing to stand by it at all costs.[/QUOTE]
Easy to say when they are abstract and hypothetical .... it is with all due likelyhood much harder to do when real.
Insert signature here.
User avatar
Bloodstalker
Posts: 15512
Joined: Wed Apr 18, 2001 10:00 pm
Location: Hell if I know
Contact:

Post by Bloodstalker »

Hard to answer. The only definate answer i can give is I would gladly allow others to die for my principles. Just fill out the lackey application :D
Lord of Lurkers

Guess what? I got a fever, and the only prescription is more cowbell!
User avatar
Magrus
Posts: 16963
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 7:10 am
Location: NY
Contact:

Post by Magrus »

[QUOTE=Bloodstalker]Hard to answer. The only definate answer i can give is I would gladly allow others to die for my principles. Just fill out the lackey application :D [/QUOTE]

I have one of those! Did I mention I'm in need of a head bartender to hire and direct more bartenders for my college? All the free Turkey you want and you get to take a set of twins home with you. One pair is looking for a home and is craving attention, poor lasses. :(
"You can do whatever you want to me."
"Oh, so I can crate you and hide you in the warehouse at the end of Raiders?"
"So funny, kiss me funny boy!" / *Sprays mace* " I know, I know, bad for the ozone"
User avatar
the_limey
Posts: 601
Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2003 8:19 pm
Location: Blighty
Contact:

Post by the_limey »

[QUOTE=Magrus]I have one of those! Did I mention I'm in need of a head bartender to hire and direct more bartenders for my college? All the free Turkey you want and you get to take a set of twins home with you. One pair is looking for a home and is craving attention, poor lasses. :( [/QUOTE]

Does this mean i can have a promotion on my fist day?
England expects...
...you to visit:
limey-simey.deviantart.com
User avatar
Magrus
Posts: 16963
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 7:10 am
Location: NY
Contact:

Post by Magrus »

[QUOTE=the_limey]Does this mean i can have a promotion on my fist day?[/QUOTE]

Nopity. Must perform in an excellent manner, unless BS doesn't want the job. Me thinks he'd be perfect for it...
"You can do whatever you want to me."
"Oh, so I can crate you and hide you in the warehouse at the end of Raiders?"
"So funny, kiss me funny boy!" / *Sprays mace* " I know, I know, bad for the ozone"
Post Reply